Higgins, 43, who won the tournament in 1999 and 2006, won three of the opening four frames, including a break of 65, to race into a 3-1 lead.
But Day, 38, fought his way back into the match with three successive breaks of 52, 111 and 83.
The Welshman finished with a 128, the highest break of the match, to clinch the deciding frame.
"It was great to finish the match like that, in one hit," Day said after the match. "Even if he thinks his game's not in great shape, he's always difficult and clever with the shots he plays."
It was frustration for Higgins once again, who faced Day in a final frame decider in Shanghai earlier this year.
"That's twice he's done that against me this year," Higgins said. "It's the right result, he played a lot better than I did, I was pretty bad."